Property fireworks unlikely in 2022
MAIN IMAGE: John Loos, FNB Real Estate Economist
It’s that time again, early in the new year, when we are speculating as to what 2022 may hold, in this case for the property part of the South African economy.
John Loos, FNB real estate economist, investigates the sector crystal ball to try and forecast what the industry is in for this year.
In a still weak, albeit improved, economy with rising interest rates, property market fireworks don’t appear to be on the cards this year. But there are some expected “relative” positives, notably the industrial property market, an expected turn for the better in the residential rental market, and an outperforming Western Cape region that may be experiencing a renewed surge in skilled and affluent “semi-grants” from elsewhere.
What themes or features should be looked out for?
Rising trend in property vacancy rate
The MSCI All Commercial Property Vacancy Rate has been on a broad multi-year rising trend, from a low of 4.3% as at the 2nd half of 2015 to 9.7% by the 1st half of 2021. We would expect this rate to move into double-digit territory in 2022, if it hasn’t already during the 2nd half of 2021. We believe that economy-wide production levels are insufficient yet to fuel sufficient commercial space demand to eat into mounting oversupply.
While FNB does project Real Gross Domestic Product (GDP), the measure of economy-wide production/output, to finally get back to the pre-Covid-19 levels of 2019, we also know that the 2019 level of GDP was insufficient back then to halt the rising vacancy trend, and we believe it will still be insufficient this time around.
After a sharp -6.4% decline in real GDP in 2020, the level of economy wide output is believed to have only partially recovered back to 2019 levels, with a +4.7% growth expectation for 2021 being insufficient to fully revive the output level. Besides certain mild lockdown restrictions having remained in place in 2021, a portion of business did not survive the shock of 2020, implying a reduction in the economy’s output capability, so it was always expected that it would take a while before that capability was restored and GDP could fully “normalize”.
The key driver of the continuation of this All Property Vacancy Rate rise is expected to be the severely underperforming Office Market.
This further rise in the national All Property Vacancy Rate is expected to sustain downward pressure on real rentals and real net operating income.
Rising interest rates
The recovery of the global economy after 2020’s hard lockdown-related recession, coupled with major global supply chain disruptions to the supply side of the economy, has unleashed a surge in inflationary pressures.
Domestically, the CPI (Consumer Price Index) inflation rate rose through much of 2021, from 2.9% year-on-year as of February last year to 5.5% by November, with petrol and food prices being key influencing factors.
This took the CPI inflation rate up to near to the 3-6% upper target limit of the SARB, which responded by raising interest rates by 25 basis points in November 2021. Three more such 25-basis point interest rate hikes are expected in 2022, taking prime rate from its current 7.25% level to 8% by year end.
The expectation of a further rise in the Government debt-to-GDP ratio, with Government finance under ongoing pressure, along with short term interest rate hiking, is expected to exert upward pressure on long bond yields and therefore property capitalization (cap) rates in 2022, with cap rates being a source of downward pressure on real commercial property values.
From a decade low monthly average of 6.9% in May 2013, the monthly average long bond yield ended the year 2021 three percentage points higher at 9.9%, and the broad rising trend is expected to continue in 2022.
The average capital value per square metre on commercial property is expected to stop falling in nominal terms in 2022, but not in “real” inflation-adjusted terms.
Despite the economy remaining weak, and only expected to get back to 2019 level of real GDP this year, 3 years later, the economy will likely be significantly improved from the hard lockdown year of 2020. We therefore expect that actual average capital values on commercial property will at least halt their decline of recent years in 2022, moving back into very low single-digit positive territory in 2022.
The multi-year correction in property values is thus in effect expected to continue in 2022, albeit at a slower pace and in real terms only.
Since the 2nd half of 2018, average capital value per square metre had declined by -9.5% as at the 1st half of 2021, according to MSCI data. But 2016 was the year in which the correction really started, in lagged response to broadly stagnating economic growth since around 2012. So, while actual valuations have dropped far less, in real terms (the proper way to assess a correction) the cumulative decline in the MSCI All Property Average Capital Value has been a significant -29% from the 1st half of 2016 to the 1st half of 2021.
Hotel property market expected to improve
While much economic activity has normalized as lockdown regulations have been eased, 3 major challenges face the battling hotel property class. Firstly, a large portion of demand for hotel rooms is non-essential in nature, and many will continue to put travel and hotel stays on the backburner. Secondly, given the successful “zoomification” of much business interaction during the lockdown period, a portion of business travel that used to take place prior to Covid-19 is likely not to return. Thirdly, South Africa has been plagued by limitations on foreign travellers to the country. Vaccine rollout is key in improving this situation, but the Sub-Saharan African region is reportedly behind with this rollout.
All these challenges are expected to be in part alleviated in 2022, enabling an improved hotel property market year, but insufficient to end this class’s underperforming of the “big 3” commercial property classes. Total hotel income for October 2021 was 32.9% down on October 2019.
Home office growth?
More employees are expected to work from the office in 2022, but not at levels sufficient to end the rising office vacancy trend yet.
The office property class is expected to be the underperformer of the 3 major commercial property classes in 2022, with its already high average national vacancy rate of 17.9% (according to MSCI data) as at the 1st half of 2021 expected to rise further.
This major class is expected to see its national average vacancy rate continue to climb in 2022, as many companies revise their office space needs down. Much has been made of the work from home (WFH) surge, and this is a key dampener of demand for office space. As lockdowns ease and economic activity trends towards “normal”, more employees will go back to their offices. The level of full-time office working won’t go back to the same levels as before the lockdowns, and as technology continues to improve, so the multi-decade trend towards greater remote work levels will resume.
But people often overlook 2 other sources of pressure on demand for office space. The first is the normal recession effect, which caused a major drop in employment numbers in the office-bound sectors of the economy. This means that, even without any increase in remote work, there are less employees in these services sectors, which would normally imply less office space needed.
In addition, the trend towards improved utilisation of desk space seems to have picked up speed of late, with “hotelling” of desk space increasing in popularity. “Hotelling” refers to a desk booking system, something FirstRand has recently implemented, meaning that employees either book a desk for a day or they don’t have one. Gone are the days’ therefore, when every employee had a desk reserved for themselves, meaning a large portion of desks standing empty much of the time. This sharing of desk space will further reduce the need in the coming years for office space.
Social distancing measures in the office often requires companies to have lower density workspace. But we believe that this is only a partial offset of the above, leaving the Office Market under pressure in 2022 with its average vacancy rate rising further.
Retail improvement likely to be harder
Retail property performance improved in 2021, but 2022 will likely make further improvement tough going. After underperforming the office market in the 2020 lockdown year, retail property made something of a comeback in 2021, and its total returns last year likely outperformed those of office property but underperformed those of industrial property. Sandwiched in between the industrial and office markets are where we expect retail property returns to stay in 2022.
Real Household Disposable Income is projected to grow further, but at a very low rate of +0.2% in 2022, following a +2.8% growth rate in 2021. Real disposable income growth is expected to be constrained by very weak employment growth, companies often attempting to use labour productivity improvement instead of employing, as they rebuild balance sheets.
Slightly higher average consumer inflation in 2022, compared with 2021, is expected, and forecast hikes in interest rates on outstanding debt would eat into disposable income further. On top of this, the long-term rising trend in the effective tax rate on households is expected to continue, with adjustments for wage inflation-related tax bracket creep being only partial.
In a financially constrained consumer environment, we would thus expect retail centres focused more on high frequency essentials, and less on luxuries and low frequency purchases, to outperform.
Industrial Property Market remains outperformer
We expect the Industrial Property Market to remain the relative outperformer of the major commercial property classes. It is the most affordable of the 3 classes, and arguably the most adaptable, and this puts it at a relative advantage when the economy is under financial pressure. In addition, it appears set to benefit in the coming years from increased online retail focus. We do question how far this outperformance can extend, as manufacturing production is mediocre at best, and economy-wide inventory levels have declined significantly in recent years, so the traditional economic fundamentals related to industrial property are not overly strong.
Residential Rental Market expects improvement
The Residential Rental Market has had a very weak period in recent years. But 2022 is expected to see some strengthening. The percentage of tenants in good standing with their landlords regarding rental payments has recovered markedly following the 2020 lockdown dip. More recently, we have just started to see signs that the national average rental vacancy rate has possibly peaked and is beginning to move lower.
A decline in vacancies would provide some mild support for something of a rental inflation recovery, early hints of which we’ve already seen.
We would expect a mild recovery in the Residential Rental Market in 2022 because of our expectation of further moderate interest rate hiking. Interest rate hiking typically curbs the 1st time buyer rush to buy homes that interest rate cutting brought from 2020 onward, that rate cut-driven buyer demand surge having helped to leave a “gaping hole” in the rental market. And with a greater portion of tenants’ income restored following the 2020 lockdown income shock, new household formation in the rental market may be ready to pick up some speed.
Residential development market
Despite the residential rental market expected to pick up moderately, it will likely still be well-supplied for 2022 at least. In addition, expected rising interest rates should likely cool home buyer demand. This leads to our expectation that we should see the number of residential units plans passed peak in the near term in 2022, and residential completions to follow suit with a mild lag.
Western Cape the outperformer with flocking semi-grants
Regarding to major regions’ property market performance, the Western Cape could be the outperformer in 2022. This expectation is based on the belief that the Western Cape’s ability to attract “semi-grant skills and purchasing power”, crucial for economic growth, has recently been enhanced. This province has been the most popular semigration destination for many years, due to the perception of the province as having a great lifestyle coupled to significant economic opportunity. It has also been seen to be a region where provincial and local government is relatively well-run. Communication and information technology has enabled businesses and individuals to be more removed from the major economic hub of Gauteng.