Rental market in trouble

Rental market in trouble

MAIN IMAGE: Johette Smuts, PayProp data analyst; Samuel Seeff, chairman Seeff Property Group; Jacqui Savage, national rentals manager Rawson Property Group.

The South African residential property market has had five months of high sales activity, especially from first-time home buyers eager to benefit from the current low interest rates. However, the picture for the rental market has been less rosy.

The residential rental market is seeing more tenants in arrears amid rising vacancies. To find the remaining good tenants estate agents need to choose wisely using a comprehensive checklist.

Good tenants are getting scarcer

The pressure felt in the rental market started well before the pandemic hit. According to John Loos, FNB’s Property Strategist, the rental component of the residential market has seen a significant multi-year slowing in rental growth. This is because as the country’s economic growth slowed increasingly tenants were struggling financially to pay their rent timeously and absorb rental escalations.

The weakening of the rental market is most clearly seen in the drop of the percentage of tenants that are in good standing with their landlords. TPN’s survey indicate a gradual drop from a decade high of 85.95% as at the 3rd quarter of 2014 to 81.52% by the 1st quarter of 2020. Then came the severe lockdown in the 2nd quarter in response to the Covid-19 pandemic and the percentage of tenants in good standing dropped sharply to 73.5%. A breakdown of the situation in the three top performing provinces showed Western Cape in the lead with 80.86% of the tenants in the province in good standing, followed by noticeably lower figures in KZN (70.83%) and Gauteng (71.1%). Overall, Loos notes that the Western Cape weathered the Covid-19 storm best of the three leading provinces.

“We believe that these economy-related pressures have contributed to a greater oversupply of rental space relative to demand, with new household formation slowing and a portion of existing households ‘shutting down’, as reflected in a rising residential rental property vacancy rate,” Loos explains.

More tenants are in arrears

It is now common knowledge that thousands of tenants were unable to pay rent during the ‘hard’ months of lockdown due to loss of income or because they lost their jobs. PayProp data shows that for June through August, on average tenants were in arrears with just over one month’s rent (105% of rent). Before lockdown this figure was below 80% says Johette Smuts, data analyst with PayProp. She adds that the number of tenants in arrears also increased from 19% in March to 26% in May. “Many people returned to work again in June, so we see that this number dropped slowly from June to August – but there are still more tenants in arrears than before lockdown,” Smuts says.

Higher rental vacancy rate

On a more positive note, the sudden drop in the interest rate combined with a favourable home loan climate, has also seen an unexpected uptick in home buying activity, also from former tenants for whom it has become cheaper to buy than to rent. Since June, South Africans have been buying homes as if it is a Black Friday sale, says Samuel Seeff, chairman of the Seeff Property Group. “Buyers continue flocking to the market to take full advantage of the low interest rate and favourable bank lending climate. Approval rates are still at over 80% and some two thirds of buyers are still securing full or close to full bonds,” he says. In many areas, property is more affordable than renting. A R1.5 million property would for example only cost you around R12 000 per month on a bond compared to a rent of about R14 000. Seeff adds that they are seeing a massive influx of first-time buyers. A Q3 FNB survey estimate that first-time buyers are responsible for 24% of total buying in an expanding market, up from 19% a year prior.

Loos confirms that the sudden reduction in the interest rate has increased the attractiveness of owning a home relative to the rental option. This buying spree further contributed to the exodus of tenants, increasing the current vacancy rate. From a low of 5.35% in the final quarter of 2017, the TPN National Average Vacancy Rate has steadily been climbing over the last few years to reach 11.39% by Q3 of 2020, and it is still climbing says Loos.

In fact, the average rental inflation at 1.4% is now slower than the FNB House Price inflation rate which accelerated to 3.14% year-on-year in September this year. This does not bode well that the rental market will soon see an upswing in rental growth. According to Loos it is more likely that the rental market could weaken further in the coming months with a period of average rental deflation possible in 2021.

Changing rental needs

The lockdown and ongoing need for social distancing has changed what people look for in an apartment and these changes appear to be long-term. “We’ve seen that with the lockdown-imposed work-from-home situation, tenants are now less likely to be driving into an office even after lockdown. This means that they can consider renting in suburban areas, further from the city, where rental properties are often priced more affordably. In addition, their new work-from-home status means that they’ll likely need a study or additional bedroom for a home office,” says Smuts.

Finding good tenants

With so many good tenants moving out to become first-time homeowners, the biggest challenge for rental and estate agents will be finding the remaining good tenants says Smuts. “By that we mean those with acceptable credit scores, sufficient funds for a once-off damage deposit and sufficient monthly disposable income to pay the rent. The tenants that remain also have far greater bargaining power when it comes to rental prices, as the oversupply of stock affects the rental market too,” she explains.

Jacqui Savage, national rentals manager for the Rawson Property Group recommends that estate agents use a checklist when evaluating new tenants that include the following:

  1. Good financial track record

It is important to choose a responsible tenant with a good financial track-record, who can respect the rental property and the lease agreement. First of all a prospective tenant would have to fill out a Declaration of Expenses document as well as an application form to kick off the vetting process. That application form grants consent for the rental agency to perform various credit checks that give them a comprehensive overview of the applicant’s finances and reliability profile.

Compiling that overview includes collecting the following details:

  • A credit and identity check through the Credit Bureau
  • Confirmation of income and employment via payslips and a call to the employer
  • Confirmation of monthly expenses via 3-months of verified bank statements
  • Personal references from previous landlords (if applicable) by phone call
  1. Reference check

Ask for contactable references to confirm the applicant’s personal character and prior rental history and experience. The references must be able to vouch for the applicant’s employment, responsibility in timely payments, cleanliness and the ability to look after a property.

  1. Defaulting tenants

When a tenant defaults the rental agents are equipped with the relevant breach documentation that are CPA compliant and ensure that the relevant breach documents are issued within certain time frames. It is vitally important to issue these documents to prevent a tenant from defaulting repeatedly. It also ensures that the landlord follows the correct processes, should there be a need to take this further with legal counsel.

Finally, estate agents and property owners, may need to debate where the biggest risk lies: a prospective tenant with a low credit score and a double deposit versus a tenant with a good credit score but without the full deposit – or no tenant at all.

Showing 9 comments
  • les

    Great article!

  • Corne Putter

    We have a 63 year old lady, saying in one of our flats. She haven’t paid rent for almost 2 years now. Do you have any tips on how to get her our of the apartment

    • Marc

      2 years? That is crazy. Hire a specialized eviction lawyer.

  • Charl

    Solid article!



  • Howard

    Makes me nervous that good tenants are so few and far between

  • Mongezi Bunyonyo

    My tenant has not paid rent since the beginning of the lockdown in March 2020.
    He was not being paid by his job, because his job relies on the tourism industry.

    So, he has not paid rent for the past 9 months. I don’t know what to do and where to start legally.

  • Warren

    Its all well to do the checklist for new tenants, but things can change in a minute, then where does that leave the tenants? To me it seems to be that the law will most definitely be with the landlords. Property owners should decide do they want a good tenant or no tenant at all. In these times we are finding ourselves it’s hard to just cough up 3 months deposit and 1st months rent. I do understand that property owners want good tenants that can afford to pay their bonds for the property that they bought but where does it leave the tenant? In Cape Town, in particular, rent is way too high compared to the other provinces. How do property owners expect to comply with all this legislative paperwork? After all, you are not buying the property, you are renting it in turn helping someone else to pay their bond. I feel that there is just no concern for rental tenants and their rights.

  • Stella

    Great article but it would be great if landlords could also be vetted by prospective tenants because some landlords don’t keep their end of the agreement.

Leave a Comment

Start typing and press Enter to search